Skinpress Demo Rss

Adam Lambert vs Siobhan Magnus in a Scream Off

Filed Under ( ) by Admin on Saturday, May 1, 2010

Posted at : Saturday, May 01, 2010



SOURCE: MTV

30 comments:

Anonymous said...

Oh, I find this comparison SO annoying. It creates the conversation that they are even on the same level of vocal capability. No comparison. No comparison. No comparison. She screams...and a little off tune at times. Adam sings power notes with great control. The fact that her singing was ever compared to Adam's in the first place is just plain wrong. She seems like a nice person and her voice is nice, but it's not the caliber of Adam's.

Anonymous said...

I agree with anon 1, this is rediculously a waste of time! I don't even want to say anything more...
Riri

Anonymous said...

no comparison,she just seems to add it at the end of a song, where for Adam it is part of his song, it can be anywhere in his song. He also has complete control of his voice, and can also bring it down completely under control.

Anonymous said...

omg please do not compare these two..i couldnt stand her screaming for no reason off key. she is horrible. adam is amazing with such range and control. dont even put them in the same category.

Anonymous said...

she is a girl, wouldn't she have a high scream any way, prolly just saw a mouse ha ha ha. Adam doesn.t scream, he sings

Anonymous said...

This comparison is just an insult to Adam incomparable voice and talent ! I won't even comment on Siobhan's screeching....

jordan!! said...

adam is waaaaaaaaay better and he sounds good when he does it she dont!

Anonymous said...

How SILLY!!
siobhan so wants everyone to think she is as good as Adam,she is so deluded!! she even said to Adam everyone thinks i sound like you!! simon was right to put her down so glad she's History
Love our Glam Sex God ADAM so much xx
bye bye siobhan never to be heard of again hopefully

Anonymous said...

do a duet on the finale

Anonymous said...

no disrespect to Siobhan cuz I really liked her and I'm sad she got voted off (this years' AI sucks dick) but Adam is better than she is vocally, a lot better. maybe she needs some more time and she'll learn how to control her voice more. Adam is almost 10 years older than she is.

Anonymous said...

no comment

Anonymous said...

I usually love your posts adamlamberttv, but not this one. Completely irrelevant. It's like comparing a real diamond (Adam Lambert) and a fake one (Siobhan). One will cut glass, the other will only scratch it!

Anonymous said...

This is really an insult to anyone's intelligence, how could you compare incredible vocals, real super star talented singer (Adam Lambert) with someone that what she does is just SCREAM OUT OF KEY....no consideration to real music!!!!!!!!is anybody listening!!!!!
offensive!!!!!!!!

Anonymous said...

I agree that this is an insult to compare ANYONE to Adam ,let alon this girl. I didn't even play it, I knew that I am not going to like it and I was right by all your comments.

Anonymous said...

I like SM but comparing her to Adam is not doing *her* any favors while she is still developing as an artist-- it's probably hurting her. Anyone she signs with is going to see she's not there yet. My guess AI is floating these talking points to try and bring relevance to their show.

Anonymous said...

I like her but I have to agree with everyone else that Adam wins hands down. MTV did this to create senseless fan wars lol.

Anonymous said...

This is insulting to Adam. Adam does not scream. He sings. Please don't post these types of articles.

Anonymous said...

Pure STUPID~~~~No Comparison to Adam.

Anonymous said...

Ditto. This is insulting to Adam.
There is no comparison. Adam is a master with an amazing, beautiful voice. Siobhan is screeches.
Im glad Simon called her on it, but I wouldn't say her screech was fun (like he did). It's annoying. Not fun!

Anonymous said...

Its stupid to have Adam's name in a title that says "Scream-off." Ridiculous. Adam os a fabulous somger.

Anonymous said...

I'm glad she's gone. No one compares to Adam. She screeches, he sings and to get to the high notes, he sticks his tongue out to open his throat more. He's got the technique. SM sounds like my three year old daughter throwing a tantrum. EWWW

Anonymous said...

She can go in a scream-off with Danny Gokey, but not Adam. He sings.

Anonymous said...

I think the judges were absolutely spot on with what they said about SM, spot on. And honestly, call me jaded, but I truly think the judges were using reverse psychology when they spoke positively about her performance last week, which was equally as unimpressive and off as prior weeks, because they feared that being too harsh on her would only serve to compel more people to dial for her. SM has POTENTIAL, but her performances, on AI which is obviously all I can speak to, were uneven and, quite plainly, just not that enjoyable IMO. She is lucky to be going on the tour, something the uber talented Lilly Scott would love to be doing I'm sure, and I hope she grows with the experience. I won't even speak to any comparison to Lambert - that's just silly.

Anonymous said...

golden rule, if you don't have nice things to say, just don't say it.

Anonymous said...

This is a joke, right? They're not in the same league by a long shot, only in her dreams can she compare herself to someone of Adam's talent.

Anonymous said...

Golden rule doesn't apply to the real world. Show business can be brutal. If you can't stand the heat....... SM is cute, but she does not have much of a voice. Nothing was ever together, and I agree with judges that she was all over the place. With maturity and some voice training, maybe she will make it, but she won't as she currently presents.

Anonymous said...

Simon was right, SM's scream reminded me of my own when I was giving birth. Adam on the other hand, uses his high notes as an integral part of his music. No comparison, not even a contest.

Anonymous said...

Yes I so agree with most of the above comments on SM. She CAN'T sing!!! She's always screaming and I don't know what makes Kara compared her to Adam??

Adam is 1 billion times better in his singing, stlye and everything... compared to SM who has not much of a talent!!!

Please I don't want to see articles like this in the future!! No one can be compared to our TALENTED ADAM LAMBERT!!!

Anonymous said...

Simply put: Adam sings pitch perfect with a technically gifted voice. Siobhan intermittently screams. I do think she has singing talent, but needs voice lessons to learn to technically sing and hold pitch if she wants to do high notes.

Anonymous said...

Zero comparison. Adam is on pitch and can take it to any octave with control. Sioban is just learning she can make such sounds and doesn't have control and she isn't always on pitch. Just dumb to compare actually.